Like with all things related to insurance or taxes, whether or not an insurance settlement is taxable depends on the situation you have found yourself in. Once you file an insurance settlement or claim, the money you receive does not tend to be taxable. However, in some cases, this money is subject to taxes. Unfortunately, many people don’t realize they have to pay taxes on their settlement until it is a little too late.

The IRS levies taxes based on income alone. If you receive a payment from your insurance, in most cases, you will only receive enough to cover the situation at hand. If the money you receive to cover damages is just enough to fix the issue you have run into, it should not be taxable.

There are quite a few factors that determine whether or not a settlement is taxable. There can always be exceptions that complicate things even more. The origin of the claim plays a role in whether or not something is taxable. This factor determines if what you receive is considered income.

The IRS has addressed the taxability of settlements in their language. Their wording can be confusing for anyone who has never been in this situation before. In most cases, money issued from a claim is not taxable, but there are some instances where it may be. It all just depends. Let’s take a look at some specific examples.

>>MORE: Why Is Life Insurance Important? (Top Important Reasons )

What claims are not taxed?

In most cases, your insurance claim income is not taxable. The compensation received is unlikely to help you go further in life but rather fix damages or resolve an incident that may have occurred. If you are not gaining anything from your settlement but rather breaking even, there is little chance that this money is taxable.

To help explain this further, here are a few examples of settlements that are not subject to taxes.

Property repair or replacement

When a property is damaged, those with insurance often file claims to receive money to fix the issues. These claims can include repairs or replacements of cars, homes, or other property types. Property damage is a common occurrence. Sometimes this damage occurs from a natural disaster or even vandalism.

In the majority of these cases, the settlements will not be taxable. People tend to receive just enough money to cover what they need. It is unlikely that they would receive additional income that would need to be taxed. This money would be taxable if a person was given more than necessary to repair or replace the property.

Medical and personal injury settlements

In situations where you need to file a medical claim, you will not be taxed. In most of these settlements, you will receive just enough compensation to cover your medical expenses and physical injuries. If you are not left with additional income, there is no reason for you to be taxed.

When it comes to health insurance claims, there are few instances when you would be in charge of distributing money you received from your insurance to doctors or other medical professionals. In most cases, your insurance provider will take care of this directly.

In cases involving emotional distress, these settlements can be taxable. Again, this tends to vary. If this is not a direct result of an illness or injury, the funds will likely be taxable.

Punitive damages, also known as exemplary damages, can occur with a personal injury. These damages go beyond simple compensation, and settlements like this are taxable.

>>More: How To Choose A Life Insurance Beneficiary | How To Lower Car Insurance? | Is My Old Life Insurance Policy Worth Anything | Life Insurance VS. 401(k): What’s The Difference

Car accident settlement

Depending on the type of loss from your car accident, the settlement you receive may or may not be taxable. In most cases, it is not. H&R Block explains that this does not have to be included in your income if you are compensated for an injury, personal pain, or suffering.

According to H&R Block, this may be taxable. You may be taxed if you reported medical expenses that resulted from your car accident in a prior year as itemized deductions. The same goes for if the funds received were given to you for something else, such as reimbursement for the income you lost.

It is unlikely you will need to pay taxes on the money you receive after a car accident. The same goes for car repairs, replacement, or any money given to you for a rental car you may have needed while waiting for yours to be drivable again.

If punitive damages occurred in the car accident, keep in mind that these are always taxable.

>>MORE: How Much Does Flood Insurance Cost? (Full Pricing Guide)

In some cases, income from insurance claims and settlements is taxable.

If you are receiving more money than is needed to resolve an issue at hand, this may be considered taxable income. Sometimes insurance companies overpay, and other times people find cheaper ways to repair or replace what the settlement was meant for, resulting in leftover money. Interest is always taxable as well.

Life insurance claims

Life insurance payouts that people receive upon the death of a loved one are not taxed. Life insurance is not subject to income tax as long as the money is given as a single payment in one lump sum. However, there are some cases in which people may have to pay taxes from life insurance.

Occasionally life insurance is taxed as part of an estate. This happens when the amount inherited exceeds federal and state exemptions. If the beneficiary receives money in installments, this money would be taxable. Another instance when life insurance may be taxed is when people take funds out of a life insurance policy while the person it belongs to is still alive. These funds are considered income.

Disability insurance claims

According to the IRS, any amount received for disability must be reported as income. Those who receive money through their disability insurance may have to pay taxes in some cases. H&R Block explains that you will not pay income tax on benefits that come from a disability policy that had premiums paid with after-tax dollars.

Those who receive benefits through Social Security will not have to pay taxes on this. They tend to have no additional income.

Lost Income compensation

When you receive a settlement to take care of the income you have lost, this money is subject to income tax. This is because the money you received through your settlement is meant to replace an equal amount to what you would have made. The money you lost would have been taxable anyway. If you were given more than you lost through your settlement, this additional amount is taxable as well.

Lawsuit proceeds

Some insurance claims end up heading down the road to a lawsuit. Taxes get a little trickier when it comes to lawsuits. In some cases, legal settlements are taxable, but in other cases, they are not. It depends on the way the case was handled, what damage occurred, and other facts. Keep in mind that the same tax rules apply to both settlements and judgments.

When a lawsuit occurs, there tend to be multiple factors to consider. A lawsuit can lead to more than one settlement, and things get a bit more intricate. Another thing to consider here is attorney fees. Unfortunately, in most cases, even if your lawyer received a decent portion of your settlement in fees, the amount you originally received is what is considered income. There tends to be no deduction for legal fees.

>>MORE: Why Is Business Insurance Important? (Top Important Reasons )

Many factors play a role in deciding whether or not a settlement will be taxable.

In most cases, what you receive through a settlement is not taxable, but there are some instances where it might be. The big thing to keep in mind here is that the IRS only taxes money that makes you wealthier than you were before.

It would be much easier if there were a simple answer to whether or not settlements are taxable. Unfortunately, that’s not the case. Sometimes this is straightforward, but some exceptions complicate the situation. If you find yourself needing to pay taxes on an insurance claim, you should obtain a 1099 form. These forms come in handy when reporting non-employment income.

Note: The money you get as part of an insurance settlement or claim is not taxed. Interestingly, the IRS only levies taxes on income – this is the payment received that results in you creating more wealth than you did before. Meanwhile, this also applies to the insurance plan you opt for when subscribing to Lemonade Insurance Company. The company doesn’t charge service or extra tax fees.

Try Lemonade

>>MORE: How Much Does A Chiropractor Cost Without Insurance?

If you are still unsure whether or not your settlement is taxable, you should reach out to someone for more advice.

Tax laws could change at any time, so it is vital to keep up-to-date on this information. Laws can differ from state to state and depend on where you live. It is best to check both state and federal income tax laws.

Making a mistake when it comes to taxes can be costly. Do not hesitate to reach out for advice if you need it. If you have any questions about whether or not you will need to pay taxes on your settlement, ask your lawyer or insurance provider. This confusion comes up often, and your question has likely been asked many times before. They should be able to help you. If they are not experts themselves, they can connect you with someone who is.

>>MORE: Mortgage Insurance vs. Homeowners Insurance: What’s the Difference?

Read More